Every organisation tells itself the same story: some people have it, most don’t. In that story the rainmaker is a natural, and the rest of the team should be glad he exists. It is a comforting story, because it releases everyone from the duty to learn it. It is also demonstrably wrong.

The experiment nobody wanted to run

Boris Groysberg followed more than a thousand star analysts on Wall Street, people ranked among the best in their field year after year (Groysberg 2010). When those stars changed employers, something happened that the talent myth cannot explain: their performance dropped immediately, and stayed below their old level for years, up to five years after the move. Same person, same talent, different house, less rain.

The explanation was not in the person but in what stood around the person: the colleagues who fed them files, the internal networks, the reputation of the house, the systems and routines. One telling detail: stars who moved with their entire team suffered no performance loss. The talent was not portable. The system was.

Rain is a team sport that doesn’t look like one

Translate that to the rainmaker in your own company. What looks like personal magic is in reality an ensemble: the references the company built, the colleagues who deliver on what he promises, the stories he can tell because others wrote them. The rainmaker is real, his talent is real, but the rain falls from a cloud the whole company forms together. I have seen it in client work for twenty years: the strong salesperson who leaves, and the revenue that turns out not to be in his suitcase, or that is, precisely because nobody ever made the relationship wider than that one name. Whoever sees that asks a different question. Not: where do I find another talent like this? But: how do I make the cloud bigger?

Learnable, therefore transferable

Ford Harding wrote the classic on this thirty years ago: professionals who had never sold anything become reliable rainmakers when you break the craft into learnable pieces, from networking to the first conversation (Harding 2008). That is not a plea to turn every expert into a salesperson. It is the observation that the rainmaker’s behaviour, made visible and practised, is transferable. What is not transferable is the myth.

Talent is not portable. The system is.

In practice: ask your best rainmaker to track for one week what he does before, during and after every client contact. Put that list next to what your team does. The difference is not talent, it is a curriculum.

References

  • Groysberg, Boris. 2010. Chasing Stars: The Myth of Talent and the Portability of Performance. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
  • Groysberg, Boris, Ashish Nanda, and Nitin Nohria. 2004. “The Risky Business of Hiring Stars.” Harvard Business Review, May 2004.
  • Harding, Ford. 2008. Rain Making: Attract New Clients No Matter What Your Field. 2nd ed. Avon, MA: Adams Media.

Series · From rainmaker to rainmaking · Add Business

Want to take this further?

This insight does not stand alone. Explore the other parts of this series and take the next step in your own course.

View the full series

Share